Facebook Badge

Navigation Menu

THE LOVE MEN WERE TAUGHT TO FEAR


 

There is a peculiar tragedy in the way many men are conditioned to conceive love.

 

From childhood, a boy begins absorbing the code: admire your father, compete with your brother, play with your friends, fend for those you care about and, eventually, fall in love with a woman. But somewhere between childhood and manhood, a shrewd tenet starts to take root without ever declaring itself, until the boy misjudges it for truth:

 

Do not become too ardently attached to another man.

 

Care too much and people will wonder.

 

Speak too soft-heartedly and someone will laugh.

 

Miss your friend and you will be teased.

 

Tell another man that you love him and the word love suddenly becomes dangerous.

 

Crave to be beside him when he is suffering, remember the smallest things about his life, fret about his welfare, stand alongside him when the world has turned against him, or humbly tell him, I am here—and an ethos that has spent eras confusing masculinity with cathartic caginess may begin searching for a sexual paraphrasing for what is, in fact, an entirely human one.

 

This is one of the unspoken contours of male insecurity. And surely the time has come to publicise it without embarrassment.

 

Psychological scholarship has been telling us for decades that boys and men are usually socialised to suppress vulnerability, quell disclosure and dependence upon others. The American Psychological Association notes that boys are often fraternised from an early age to regard the admission of tangibility as something unbecoming; the wider psychological literature has repeatedly connected xenophobic sentimental patterns with poorer psychological outcomes and frailer bosom friendships. (American Psychological Association)

 

The problem, thus, is not that men are incapable of great friendship. The problem is that many men come to inquest the very capacity for it.

 

The boy inherits the conventions before he is old enough to understand their consequences

 

To a little boy, tenderness between two boys is basically tenderness; the suspicion comes later. 

 

He does not look at his closest friend and think, I must be careful not to care about him too much.

 

Children utterly attach. They seek companionship. They confide. They sit close. They become shielding. They become fascinated by one another’s personalities. They miss each other. They itch to be understood. Then society begins correcting them.

 

Psychologist Ronald Levant and others have explored what has been called normative male alexithymia—the difficulty some men develop in identifying and enunciating emotions after years of indoctrination to quash them. Levant describes how, through childhood peer customs, boys progressively imbibe to police their own incandescent reflections. (American Psychological Association)

 

And another lesson often accompanies it:

 

Masculinity must distinguish itself from femininity—and heterosexuality must distinguish itself from homosexuality.

 

Thus a boy does not merely master what a man is. He cultivates what a man must not grow to be. That contrast is crucial. Because once masculinity is constructed through avoidance—don’t cry, don’t be a pussy, don’t be vulnerable, don’t be affectionate, don’t appear feminine, don’t seem gay—typical human affability can become psychologically contaminated.

 

A hug becomes ambivalent. A compliment becomes cumbersome. Fealty becomes flustering. And love between friends becomes something that entails explanation.

 

A substantial body of corroboration has identified homophobia and restrictive excitability as barriers to fellowship in male friendships. A systematic review examining modern masculinities found that the type of nearness that permits men to reveal themselves to one another frequently conflicts with long-establishedexpectations of stoicism and demonstrative repression. (PubMed Central (PMC))

 

More strikingly, recently a report involving more than 3,000 adults unearthed that men remained more apprehensive than women about activities with other men that might be interpreted as romantic, suggesting that heterosexual etiquettes continue to control even ordinary male friendship. (PubMed)

 

In other words, the edginess is not imaginary. It is culturally manufactured.

 

But love is not a sexual proposition

 

There is an important distinction we have somehow become afraid to make.

 

A man can love another man without desiring him sexually.

 

He can love him fiercely.

 

He can harbour ardour for him.

 

He can worry about him.

 

He can yearn for him to be healthy and happy.

 

He can feel proud of him.

 

He can think about him when he is absent.

 

He can ache to protect him from pain.

 

He can feel that existence itself is somehow richer because that particular person is part of it.

 

None of these things, by themselves, tell us anything about sexual orientation.

 

They tell us something about troth, or in other words faithfulness. 

 

Something about friendship.

 

Something about loyalty.

 

Something about the human endowment to produce permanent bonds.

 

Sexual orientation concerns stereotypes of sexual and/or amorous attraction. Friendship, fondness, esteem, awe occupy a territory that is not reducible to sexual desire. And this matters because otherwise we commit an odd intellectual error: we assume that if an instinct is intense, it must then be sexual.

 

It is not.

 

Intensity does not determine category.

 

A mother’s love for her son can be overwhelming without being sexual. A brother’s love for his brother can be wistful without being sexual. A soldier’s devotion to a crony can be sincere without being sexual.

 

So why should friendship between two men be subjected to a disparate highbrow standard?

 

The deepest dilemma: being misread

 

There is another, more damaging dimension to this. Sometimes, a man extends another man the simple gifts of friendship, and uninhibited fidelity—and, bizarrely, the recipient interprets it sexually.

 

Perhaps he has never learned to recognise uncomplicated altruism when it is proffered to him. Perhaps he has never experienced it. Perhaps he has been steeled to believe that men do not articulate to one another in the language of a cipher unless something else is intended. Perhaps his own insecurities prevent him from accepting the possibility that someone could care for him without wanting something from him.

 

Whatever the reason, the mistake should not automatically become an accusation against the person who offered the love.

 

Being misunderstood does not make the reflex less pure.

 

And the recipient’s discomfort does not necessarily prove that any boundary was crossed. Sometimes the immaturity lies not in the one who loves, but in the one who insists that love must resemble something he already knows. 

 

That does not mean boundaries should be ignored.

 

They should not.

 

If someone says that a certain illustration of devotedness disturbs them, their boundary deserves respect. Love does not entitle us to access another person’s unreserved space.

 

But there is a universe of difference between saying,

 

“This is more emotional comradeship than I am comfortable receiving,”

 

and saying,

 

“Your love must therefore be sexual, inappropriate or indisposed.”

 

The first is self-awareness.

 

The second may straightforwardly be misperception.

 

And this is where the refined man becomes reticent

 

There is an excruciating wisdom in knowing when to withdraw from the situation. Suppose you know, with absolute clarity, that your feelings are clean. You have no sexual intention. No private design. No appetite to acquire. You totally care. And yet the person receiving that care insists upon interpreting it through a sexualised lens. What should you do? Perhaps the most dignified answer is neither row nor resentment.

 

Be there. Let your presence be enough.

 

Care from a distance. Wish him well. Do not abandon him because he has not yet comprehended how to concede the bracket of love you are giving him. But do not continually place your heart where it will be mislabelled, mistrusted or made to feel chagrined of its own goodness. There is nothing noble about continually donating your most unguarded defencelessness to someone who insists on treating it as something dirty.

 

In such circumstances, to sever is not inevitably to forfeit. It can be preservation. You can be a friend without demanding intimacy. You can wish him happiness without demanding recognition. You can aspire, without asking to witness it, that he one day discerns not to despair courtesy. And sometimes the most loving thing one can do for another human being is to step into the background, without insisting that the love be recognised for what it is. He may rely upon you more than he realises. But you also have a responsibility to yourself.

 

Your purity of perception does not necessitate another person’s approval to become real.

 

There is something terribly tragic about this

 

Men are living through an epidemic of loneliness while simultaneously being disciplined to distrust one of the things that could shelter them from it: special friendship with other men.

 

The evidence is hardly ambiguous.

 

The findings increasingly indicate that orthodox masculine averages—including unrestrained restriction and disdain towards homosexuality—can erode amity between male friends. (Wiley Online Library)

 

The APA’s contemporary work on masculinity similarly argues for progressing forms of masculinity grounded in communicative connection, realism and resilience rather than rigid emotive clampdown. (American Psychological Association)

 

And this gives us an aberrant possibility. Perhaps the future of masculinity is not the elimination of strength.Perhaps it is the liberation of strength from impassioned poverty.

 

A man should be able to say:

 

“I love my friend.”

 

And there should be no occasion immediately to ask what he means.

 

He should be able to say:

 

“I was troubled about you.”

 

Without awkwardness.

 

He should be able to tell another man:

 

“You matter to me.”

 

Without having his sexuality placed on trial.

 

He should be able to keep company with a grieving friend and hold his hand without an audience bemused whether the gesture warrants a label. Because sensitivity is not the opposite of masculinity. Sensitivity is one of the things that makes solidity worthwhile.

 

Perhaps we have been asking the wrong question

 

When two men share an inordinately radical friendship, why must we still ask:

 

“Is there something sexual going on?”

 

And begin asking:

 

“What if this is easily what friendship looks like when two human beings have finally stopped being frightened of caring?”

 

That query unfastens a different horizon altogether. It accords men to have friendships that are warm and nourishing rather than just recreational. It indulges them to discuss grief, failure, fear, ageing, alienation, desolation, and uncertainty without acknowledging that they have somehow surrendered their masculinity. It authorises a man to say, I need you, without believing that habituation has made him flimsy. And it obliges another man to answer, I am here, without fantasising that propensity must have an agenda.

 

That is not a threat to masculinity. It may be its maturation.

 

The hope

 

There is, ultimately, something acutely anticipative here. Cultures change. The rules handed down to boys are but the dispositions of men, not the immutable ordinances of nature. They are taught. And what is taught can be untaught.

 

Psychological research increasingly points to fervid connexion, relational competence and authenticity as improving foundations for male identity. Programmes aimed to challenge closed-door masculine norms have previously demonstrated improvements in areas such as chumminess and mental health. (American Psychological Association)

 

So we might yet bequeath the next generation of boys a diverse vocabulary. A boy should be able to love his friend without having to defend the word love. A man should be able to care for another man without primarily having to confirm his heterosexuality. A friendship should be endorsed to become untainted without becoming suspicious. And when love is misconstrued, the mature response is not retaliation but restraint. We can simply retreat. Stay benevolent. Stick around if incumbent. And grant time to teach what argument cannot. Because there is something categorically revolutionary about a man who refuses to be mortified of his capability to love another man virtuously, generously and without possession and proprietorship. 

 

He is not less of a man. He may, in fact, be a more complete one. For the truest measure of masculinity is not how successfully a man can conceal his stances, but how courageously he can carry them without turning them into weapons, ultimatums or shame.

 

A civilisation in which men are free to love their friends without infamy will not become spineless. It will honestly become more human.

 

It may become a kinder one. And this is the manner of masculinity worth tutoring our sons.

 



0 comments: